Never give a toddler a choice between a good option and a bad one. In other words, don’t ask, “Do you want to get dressed?” Instead, say, “Do you want to wear the red shirt or the blue shirt?”
My father-in-law learned this the hard way when, looking at an impossibly high pile of hot French fries in front of a small body, said, “can I please have one?” and got a fast, “No.”
While we don't like to infantilize partner, we also shouldn't allow partner to make a bad choice in the auction. Too many times, players make bids that I would describe as “inadvertently invitational.” When you make one of these bids, you are allowing partner to make a bad choice.
Unfortunately, a lot of players only realize a bid wasn’t forcing when they see their partner’s pass card. Even then, I sometimes see the player who invited yelling at their partner for passing.
One key thought is that there are very few auctions where repeating a suit that’s been bid is forcing (particularly if you exclude 2/1 Game Forcing auctions).
Lets look at a common one:
You, South, hold:
AKQ654
2
AJ5
QJ4The auction goes:
| West | North | East | South |
|---|---|---|---|
1![]() | Pass | 1![]() | |
| Pass | 2![]() | Pass | ? |
Many players will bid 3
, but that is a bid that can be passed. If you aren't sure whether partner will find your next call forcing, it’s better to bid either 3NT or 4
to simplify the auction. There IS a call that would be forcing— 3
which is somewhat articifial (not a convention, but it doesn't have to be a real suit) and forcing. It may still be difficult to figure out whether you belong in spades or notrump later, but the 3
bid gives your partner another opportunity to raise spades.
Here's another common one players get wrong:
You, South, hold:
A543
KQ10
5
AKJ94The auction goes:
| West | North | East | South |
|---|---|---|---|
1![]() | |||
| Pass | 1![]() | Pass | ? |
Point count afficionados will say, "17 HCP is an invitational bid". I say, "Yuck!" If you bid three spades, your partner will pass with a variety of minimums that make game virtually laydown:
KJ109
84
J432
Q76
. You might make an overtrick in 4
. Don't give partner this bad choice. Heck, even if your partner has a sub-minimum:
K10762
765
432
87, you have a chance to make a game (possibly with an overtrick!).