Here's a lead problem from the 2009 Trials you are sure to get wrong
(maybe that will help you get it right?):
A 7 6 5 3
9
9 8 3 2
10 4 3
LHO, who is trailing late in the match, opens 2, strong. This is the auction:
LHO | Partner | RHO | You |
---|---|---|---|
2![]() | Pass | 2![]() | Pass |
3![]() | Pass | 3![]() | Pass |
6![]() | Pass | 7![]() | Pass |
Pass | Double | Redouble | All Pass |
What is your choice? Maybe partner's double is Lightner, asking for dummy's first suit. Could he be void in diamonds? But, declarer redoubled. No doubt, he is ready for a diamond lead. Or, maybe he is just redoubling because he trails in the match. Maybe you should try to cash your A first? This was the full deal:
Vul: N-S Dir: West | ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | lt;td | gt; | lt;/td | gt; | |||
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | lt;td | gt; | lt;/td | gt; | ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | |||
lt;td | gt; | lt;/td | gt; | ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | lt;td | gt; | lt;/td | gt; |
This deal knocked out the #3-seeded JOHN DIAMOND team. Note the team name. Diamonds was the suit led by Geoff Hampson. Declarer (Melih Ozdil) soon claimed all 13 tricks for a whopping score of 2940!
Of course, a club lead would have led to down two and a score of 1000 for E-W. How could West possibly know? (Maybe if he were playing for the "CLUB" team.? Maybe East thought the double was for dummy's first-bid "suit"--clubs. When the suit is artificial, this usually isn't the way a Lightner double is used.
In any event, with or without the double, I don't see how West could ever figure out to lead a club. At the other table in the match, East-West "sacrificed" in 6 doubled down 1,100. With a club lead against 7
XX, DIAMOND would have won 19 IMPs. With the diamond lead, they lost 18 IMPs. A 37-IMP swing on opening lead!!!!
(For another huge swing on lead, see this article from 2006)