David's Well-Laid Plan

David's Well-Laid Plan

See if you can match my partner, David Berkowitz's detailed analysis on this deal from the first session of the Reisinger teams in San Francisco (2007):

A 3
4
K 10 9 7 3 2
Q 8 5 3
K J
A 9 6 3
8 6 4
K J 6 4
WestNorthEastSouth
Pass1*
12Pass2N
Pass3PassPass
3Pass3Pass
Pass3NT**Double4
PassPassDoubleAll Pass

*Precision (could be short)

**Takeout

The auction is an eye full. Let me try to summarize.

David systemically opened 1 (because 1 would have been strong).

After showing a limit raise, I attempted to bail out in 3 (a fine contract). LHO balanced and then in turn, I balanced to try to reach 4 or 4. David ended in 4X--not a terrible contract.

The K was led to David's A. He played a diamond and LHO won the ace. Another heart tapped dummy and the K revealed the 3-1 break (LHO throwing a spade). Now what?

All you need is to play clubs for one loser. David carefully came to his spade king and led the 4 to LHO's 7, dummy's queen and RHO's ace. RHO cashed his good trump and tapped dummy with another heart. You play a low club from dummy and RHO plays the deuce. The moment of truth has arrived.

David put in the 6!

He played RHO for A109x. His reasoning was as follows: RHO was willing to defend against 3. Accordingly, he probably had only 3-card spade support for his partner. That meant RHO was 3=3=3=4 and LHO was 6=5=1=1. (The opponents had no Michaels bid available over the Precision 1).

Good thinking partner. Alas, the full deal was:

Vul:
Dlr:
A 3
4
K 10 9 7 3 2
Q 8 5 3
Q 9 8 4 2
K Q J 10 2
A
10 7
10 7 6 5
8 7 5
Q J 5
A 9 2
K J
A 9 6 3
8 6 4
K J 6 4

As you see, this brilliant plan failed. The 6 lost to the 10, down 1. All of my students would have brought in this club suit for only one loser. I suppose I had the wrong partner this time. (The other table played our cards in 3NT undoubled down 2, for a tied board).

**Addendum June, 2013

After dummy ruffed the 2nd heart, calmly play clubs twice, toward king and jack.If West shows out on 2nd round, ruff a heart and cash spades to end in hand. Now play the 4th heart and discard a club. Dummy's last club goes on the ruff and discard in next trick.Reported byTommy Skalmer?s,Trondheim, Norway