Site is almost complete. Please bear with us. Subscriptions are unavailable.

An Expert Should Get it Right

An Expert Should Get it Right

This deal was (mis)played in the finals of the 2018 U.S. Team Trials. South held:

AKQ874
♥ 93
♦ Q3
♣ A85.

With nobody vulnerable, his partner passed and RHO opened a weak 2. I'd be fine with a 3 overcall (showing an intermediate hand like this and a good 6+ card spade suit). However, at the table, 2 was chosen. LHO raised to 4 and partner's 4 bought the contract.

The A was led:

J1062
♥ A6
♦ J75
♣ Q973
AKQ874
♥ 93
♦ Q3
♣ A85

The defense played ace, king and another diamond, ruffed and overruffed. Declarer drew trumps, finding the 2 bidder with all 3 of them. Now what?

He needed to lose only one club trick and also discard a heart on dummy's clubs. Hoping for a 3-3 break with the king on his left, declarer played ace and another club. This was the Real Deal:

Vul:None
Dlr: North
J1062
♥ A6
♦ J75
♣ Q973
--
♥ Q52
♦ AK9842
♣ J1062
953
♥ KJ10874
♦ 106
♣ K4
AKQ874
♥ 93
♦ Q3
♣ A85

West correctly played low on the second club ("splitting" his honors could have proved disastrous). Declarer could try dummy's Q (resulting in down 2), but he guessed to play low, but still down 1 (East took the K and the defense still had to get a heart trick).

So, how could declarer have made it? The bidding and play marked East with 3=6=2=2 shape (he opened a weak two bid in hearts and showed up with 3 spades and 2 diamonds). Knowing he had only 2 clubs, the right play is clear. Go to dummy and lead a club to the 8! This "intrafinesse" wins the contract. West wins this trick, but later the A drops the king and a marked finesse in clubs allows declarer to throw his heart on the fourth club for +420.

Note that the defense could have prevailed with a heart shift at trick 2.