For the 1,000th time

By: Larry Cohen

For the 1,000th time

I have a new most-asked question. It used to be: "Should I open 1NT with a 5-card major."

Now, because I seem to have been asked 1,000 times, the new "hot topic" has become an issue with 2/1Abbreviation for Game Forcing GFand responding in a major or minor.

The basic question goes like this: "Larry, I have opening-bid strength with a 4-card major. Do I respond in the major, or with a 2/1Abbreviation for Game Forcing GFresponse?"

For example, what is the response to 1 holding:

K765
♥ A2
♦ K3
♣ AJ1062?

Either 1 or 2 would be technically acceptable. I strongly prefer 2. You won't lose a 4-4 spade fit. Your side still has plenty of time to reach spades. Meanwhile, the auction is more comfortable. I will explain this a few paragraphs later.

BUT -- Don't invent bids. Don't respond in a "non-suit." With, say,

AQJ6
♥ K87
♦ K762
♣ Q3,

respond 1 (you don't have enough clubs to bid 2).

With a 5-card major, respond in the major. So, 1 is your response to 1 with:

AJ876
♥ A6
♦ K3
♣ Q872.

(2 would be a jump-shift, and has nothing to do with 2/1 GF. 2 is a bid you shouldn't make unless you and your partnership know what it means--most play it as weak.)

Also, if you don't have enough points to force to game, you mustn't respond with a 2/1Abbreviation for Game Forcing GFbid! So, respond 1 to 1 with:

K2
♥ QJ76
♦ 32
♣ Q7654.


Here is why I like starting with a 2/1Abbreviation for Game Forcing GFresponse when possible. Say opener holds:

A2
♥ 54
♦ QJ10986
♣ KQ2.

Responder holds the hand mentioned earlier ( K765 ♥ A2 ♦ K3 ♣ AJ1062).

You would belong in 5 (or 5). But, you'd belong in 3NT opposite, say:

Q9
♥ QJ2
♦ AQJ765
♣ Q8.

Auctions go more smoothly if responder can start with a 2/1 GF. Look at two of the hands above and observe how the auctions begin:

lt;tdgt;lt;/tdgt;lt;tdgt;lt;/tdgt;
OPENERRESPONDER
A2
♥ 54
♦ QJ10986
♣ KQ2
K765
♥ A2
♦ K3
♣ AJ1062
11 (not my recommendation)
23 -- cramped auction
or
12 (much better)
22
33
etc.

Notice how much more efficient the second auction is. Responder got to do "everything" without fear of being passed. In the first auction, where he responded 1, he never forced to game. His second bid gets the auction too high too fast.


Summary:

  • WithAbbreviation for Game Forcing GFstrength and only 4 in the major, respond with a 2/1Abbreviation for Game Forcing GFin a minor (assuming you have 4+ cards in that minor). So, after 1 by partner, respond 2 with a 4=2=5=2 opening bid.
  • With a 5+card major, always respond in the major.
  • With less thanAbbreviation for Game Forcing GFstrength, respond in the major (on the 1 level).
  • All of the issues here involve a 1 or 1 opening. (If the opening is 1, there is no 2/1Abbreviation for Game Forcing GFbid available; if the opening is 1, there is no possible 1-level major-suit response.)
  • Even with only a 4-card minor (if decent), I prefer to initiate a (natural) 2/1Abbreviation for Game Forcing GFauction by responding in 2-of-the-minor. The 4-4 major suit fit (if one exists) will always be located.

Notes (advanced):

  • With 6-5 (a 5-card major and a 6-card minor) andAbbreviation for Game Forcing GFstrength, it is okay to start with 2/1 in the minor and then try to bid the major twice.
  • There is an expert trend to start with 2/1Abbreviation for Game Forcing GF(typically 2) even without clubs. Just about allAbbreviation for Game Forcing GFhands are starting with the 2/1 (artificially). But, I don't recommend this for my readers/students.

QUIZ: click here