AGE AND PREEMPTION
Another facet of maturity (age?) [see Part I
of this article] is the development of a sane preemptive philosophy.
The younger they are, the more they bid. This philosophy isn't
restricted only to the young--I see many tournament players that bid every time it is
their turn. They preempt with 5-card suits, and they don't care about suit quality.
Why?
Having played such a style (in my Marty-Bergen days), I feel well
qualified to comment. Opening 2
with, say:
 52
J87642
 A32
 75
is what I'm talking about. Such actions certainly can work. You
might preempt the opponents (especially if partner can raise) and force them into a
ridiculous position. Opening 2
could easily hit a homerun. But, there is the flip side. It can often strike out. It is a
real swingy, "top-bottom" action.
I prefer to go more down the middle. I wouldn't open 2 with that hand, but would do so, with:
52
QJ9842
A32
75.
This is still not a good-enough suit/hand for the really stodgy crowd,
but I think they need to loosen up a little. They would probably need at least the 10, and maybe even that wouldn't be
sufficient. They hardly ever get dealt a hand on which they can preempt.
So, what qualifies me to recommend this middle ground? Having played all 3 styles (sound,
medium, and aggressive) I can tell you that I've seen it all. I am 100% convinced that
"medium" is the long-run winner. If I had to give up "medium," the
next-best would be "aggressive." I don't like the pain of enduring the
strikeouts, but there are almost as many homeruns and fun to make up for it. In a weak
field, especially, aggressive is not a bad way to go.
SOUND -- RED LIGHT
As far as "sound,"--count me out. I have seen first hand how
this is clearly a losing preemptive strategy. Yes, on the few deals where it comes up (you
actually get to preempt), you are usually a winner (partner gauges the auction, opening
lead, and/or defense quite well). However, the sound preempters are losing out big time by
not setting enough problems for their opponents. I love to play against such
(non)preempters. They never get in my way--life is good when the opponents are in love
with passing.
Return to Larry's homepage
|
